Best Renters Insurance in Michigan (Top 5 Best Companies): Overview, Companies, Pros & Cons

Best Renters Insurance in Michigan: Unveiling the Truth.!!!

An image illustration of Renters Insurance in Michigan
Discover the top-rated renter’s insurance options tailored for Michigan residents.

Living in Michigan is attractive for its breathtaking natural landscapes, thriving job opportunities, and reasonable cost of living.

Despite it not being a legal requirement, renters in Michigan should prioritize obtaining renters insurance.

Having coverage is vital, especially in scenarios like theft or burglary, where replacing stolen belongings such as laptops or musical instruments can lead to substantial out-of-pocket expenses, sometimes totaling thousands of dollars or more.

Renters can avoid this financial strain by securing renters insurance.

According to our research at insuranceblob, the average basic renter’s insurance in Michigan amounts to $33.73 per month or $404.76 annually.

To assist renters in selecting the most suitable insurance company, we’ve assessed factors like affordability, coverage options, methods to lower premiums, and customer service performance.

Continue reading to explore the comprehensive benefits of renters insurance.

Best Renters Insurance Companies in Michigan

  1. Lemonade – Ideal for Online and Mobile App Coverage
  2. Liberty Mutual – Best for Affordable Rates
  3. Allstate – Optimal for Multi-Policy Discount
  4. State Farm – Second Best for Affordable Rates
  5. Farmers – Top Choice for Customer Service

Lemonade: Best for Online and Mobile App Coverage

Lemonade Renters Insurance Michigan


Lemonade revolutionized the home and renters’ insurance sector by transitioning services and live customer support agents to an online platform utilizing AI.

It has emerged as a favorite among individuals who grew up in the Internet era, and it’s not hard to understand why.

Everything occurs on Lemonade’s website and app, streamlining the process and saving you time.

You can obtain instant quotes, purchase coverage, file claims, and more, all from the convenience of your home.

For residents of Michigan, Lemonade stands out as a premier option due to its user-friendly website and app, along with its ability to handle 30% of claims instantly.

In many cases, claims are processed and paid out in as little as three minutes.

Lemonade Renters Insurance Pros & Cons

  • Charitable.
  • Also sells homeowners, condo, co-op, life, car, and pet insurance.
  • You can now receive a discount if you bundle renters and auto insurance.
  • Intuitive website and app.
  • Doing all your insurance business online provides great convenience.
  • No sales agents.
  • Can’t contact a live agent.
  • Your monthly premium might be higher than $5 based on where you live and the amount of coverage you need.
  • Coverage is not nationwide.

How is Lemonade Renters Insurance Rated?

Insuranceblob Rating 4.5 out of 5.
J.D. Power (out of 1,000) Score 853
BBB Rating B+
NAIC Complaint Index Score 1.94

Liberty Mutual: Best for Cheapest Rates

Liberty Mutual Renters Insurance Michigan


If you’re a renter in Michigan seeking the most budget-friendly option for renters’ insurance, consider turning to Liberty Mutual.

Not only does it excel overall, but the online quote we obtained through Liberty’s website boasted the lowest premium, a mere $5 per month.

This positions Liberty as the most economical choice for renters’ insurance in Michigan.

However, it’s important to note that the $5 monthly rate is typically applicable only if you opt for a policy with very minimal coverage limits, typically around $5,000.

For standard coverage limits exceeding that threshold, you’re likely to pay approximately $12 monthly, still lower than State Farm.

But the perks don’t stop there. Liberty Mutual offers an array of discounts, surpassing those offered by its competitor, State Farm.

For instance, discounts such as maintaining a claims-free record, having home security systems installed, and paying your annual premium in full can all contribute to reducing your rate.

Liberty Mutual Renters Insurance Pros & Cons

  • Many ways to lower premiums.
  • Good for students and young renters due to low coverage limits.
  • A lower limit means a lower premium.
  • Easy online claims filing.
  • Customer service is available on the weekends.
  • Offers replacement cost coverage.
  • Mediocre customer service.
  • The NAIC complaint index means that Liberty received 70% as many complaints as a typical insurer.
  • Requires a minimum of $5,000 of property.
  • Discount availability varies from state to state.

How is Liberty Mutual Renters Insurance Rated?

Insuranceblob Rating 4.5 out of 5.
J.D. Power (out of 1,000) Score 834
A.M. Best – Financial Strength Rating A
BBB Rating A+
NAIC Complaint Index Score 2.37

Allstate: Best for Multi-Policy Discount

Allstate Renters Insurance Michigan


Allstate’s renters’ insurance typically comes with a higher premium compared to its rivals, specifically Liberty Mutual and State Farm.

However, this elevated rate can be mitigated through Allstate’s multi-policy discount, commonly known as bundling.

By combining renters’ insurance and auto insurance from Allstate, customers can enjoy a 10% discount on their auto policy and a 25% discount on their renter’s policy.

This bundling incentive allows Allstate to advertise a remarkably low monthly rate, starting at just $4.

Naturally, it’s important to recognize that Allstate’s initial low rate the lowest in the industry reflects its bare-bones basic renters insurance coverage.

To obtain more comprehensive protection, additional expenditures on add-ons may be necessary.

Nevertheless, Allstate offers several commendable discounts that ultimately reduce your rate.

For instance, residing in a safe neighborhood, maintaining a claims-free history for a specified period, or being retired or over the age of 55 are among the factors that qualify for discounts.

Allstate Renters Insurance Pros & Cons

An infographic illustration of Allstate Renters Insurance Pros & Cons

  • Offers the best bundling discount in the industry.
  • The online site is helpful and full of resources.
  • Ability to talk to live agent despite heavy online and app presence.
  • Different ways to customize your deductibles and coverages.
  • Discounts and policies may not be eligible for certain states.
  • Higher premium for replacement cost coverage.
  • Average claims process satisfaction.

How is Allstate Renters Insurance Rated?

Insuranceblob Rating 5 out of 5.
J.D. Power (out of 1,000) Score 837
A.M. Best – Financial Strength Rating A+
NAIC Complaint Index Score 2.05
BBB Rating A-

State Farm: Runner Up for Cheapest Rates

State Farm Renters Insurance Michigan

State Farm renters’ insurance in Michigan is celebrated for several noteworthy aspects.

Firstly, the company is renowned for its exceptional customer service, boasting numerous agents situated across every state.

Additionally, State Farm’s online presence enhances the efficiency and speed of the claims filing process.

Furthermore, State Farm provides an exceptional identity restoration plan, available as an endorsement if your personal information is stolen.

For example, if someone steals your identity and uses it for fraud, State Farm will repay you for any losses.

What really makes State Farm different is its much lower rates compared to other companies.

The average monthly premium is $13, which is lower than the typical cost of renters insurance in Michigan, usually around $15 per month according to the Insurance Information Institute.

State Farm Renters Insurance Pros & Cons

  • The complaint index from NAIC means State Farm received only 38% as many complaints as a typical insurer of its size.
  • The JD Power renter’s insurance survey rating was one of the best of any renter’s insurance company in Michigan.
  • Easy to contact an agent.
  • Easy to use intuitive website and app.
  • No limit on personal property coverage.
  • Coverage options are lacking.
  • Doesn’t offer replacement cost coverage.
  • Add-ons can be costly.
  • Offers little discounts or any unique endorsements.

How is State Farm Renters Insurance Rated?

Insuranceblob Rating 5 out of 5.
J.D. Power (out of 1,000) Score 836
A.M. Best – Financial Strength Rating A++
BBB Rating A+
NAIC Complaint Index Score 1.77

Farmers: Best for Customer Service

Farmers Renters Insurance, Michigan


In today’s world, particularly among the younger demographic, the preference for managing renters’ insurance through a company’s website or app is widespread.

This method is deemed more convenient and timesaving.

Nevertheless, despite this trend, many renters still desire the option to connect with a customer service representative when encountering issues with their policy or needing to file a claim.

Farmers stands out for its exceptional customer service, as it places great importance on fostering strong relationships between policyholders and live agents.

Farmers Renters Insurance Pros & Cons

  • Widely available.
  • Easy to contact.
  • Easy to file a claim with many options: website, app, call center, and text message.
  • Higher than average premiums.
  • Limited and fewer discounts available than many of its competitors.
  • Average coverage options.
  • Low JD Power score.

How is Farmers Renters Insurance Rated?

J.D. Power (out of 1,000) 831
A.M. Best – Financial Strength Rating A
NAIC Complaint Index 0.56


Q: Is renters insurance required in Michigan?

A: No, renters’ insurance is not legally required in Michigan, but many landlords may require it as part of the lease agreement.

Spread the love

Leave a Comment