Can I Have Two Health Insurance Plans? How to Avoid Claim Denials and Delays

Can I have two medical insurance plans? The answer is yes, but there are some things you need to know before you sign up for double coverage.

Having two health insurance plans can be beneficial in some situations, such as when you want to extend your coverage for services that your primary plan may not cover, or when you want to lower your out-of-pocket costs.

However, having two health insurance plans also comes with some challenges, such as paying two premiums and deductibles, coordinating benefits between your plans, and dealing with potential claim denials or delays.

In this article, we will explain how having two health insurance plans works, what are the pros and cons of double coverage, and how to decide if it’s right for you.

An image of medical insurance
Having two health insurance plans can be beneficial in some situations, such as when you want to extend your coverage

How To Have Two Health Insurance Plans

Embracing dual health insurance plans can be a savvy move, offering expanded coverage for services not covered by your primary plan and potential savings on out-of-pocket expenses.

Yet, it’s not without its challenges, including managing two sets of premiums, and deductibles, and navigating the intricacies of benefits coordination.

When delving into the realm of having two health insurance plans, understanding the rules of coordination of benefits is paramount.

These rules, contingent on your location and insurance providers, dictate which plan takes the lead in payments and the subsequent role of the secondary plan.

Typically, one plan assumes the primary role, stepping in as the initial payer, while the other takes on a secondary position, covering the remaining balance.

The primary plan is often associated with your role as an employee, student, or retiree, while the secondary plan tends to cover you as a dependent, spouse, or partner.

Enrolling in and paying premiums for both plans is a prerequisite for maintaining dual coverage.

It’s imperative to communicate your dual insurance status to both providers and furnish them with pertinent information about each plan. Adhering to the distinct rules and deadlines of both plans when filing claims and submitting documents is essential.

Keeping a vigilant eye on deductibles, copays, coinsurance, and out-of-pocket maximums for both plans is also crucial.

Benefits of having two health insurance plans

An infographic of Benefits Of Having Two Health Insurance Plans
Benefits Of Having Two Health Insurance Plans

Exploring the realm of dual health insurance plans opens up a range of advantages, particularly when seeking to expand coverage or cut down on out-of-pocket expenses.

However, it’s essential to be aware of the nuances and challenges that come with managing two plans.

Here are some noteworthy benefits of having two health insurance plans:

  1. Broadened Network Access: With one plan potentially being a PPO or an HMO with out-of-network benefits, you gain access to a wider network of providers and facilities, ensuring you can receive care from top-notch doctors and hospitals.
  2. Cost Savings: The secondary plan can help mitigate copays, coinsurance, and other out-of-pocket expenses by covering costs that the primary plan may not. This translates to tangible savings on your overall healthcare bills.
  3. Comprehensive Coverage: Having two plans allows for more comprehensive coverage, especially for services or treatments that might be limited or not covered by one of the plans. This is particularly beneficial when dealing with scenarios like low limits on mental health services.
  4. Security and Peace of Mind: In the face of life changes such as job loss, divorce, or retirement, having two health insurance plans acts as a safety net. It ensures you don’t face gaps in coverage or waiting periods when transitioning between plans.

If the prospect of dual health insurance plans piques your interest, a thorough comparison of benefits and costs is essential.

Additionally, familiarize yourself with the coordination of benefits rules for both plans, diligently adhering to them to steer clear of any complications or confusion when filing claims.

Making an informed decision ensures you reap the maximum benefits while navigating the complexities seamlessly.

Risks Of Having Two Health Insurance Plans

While having two health insurance plans can offer advantages in specific scenarios, it’s crucial to acknowledge the associated risks and challenges.

Here are some potential drawbacks of maintaining dual health insurance coverage:

  1. Increased Financial Burden: Juggling two premiums and deductibles may elevate your overall healthcare costs. Depending on the benefits and coverage of each plan, the savings from the secondary plan may not offset the additional expense adequately.
  2. Complex Benefit Coordination: Coordinating benefits between your plans can be intricate and time-consuming. Informing both plans about your dual coverage and providing the necessary information is essential. Strict adherence to the rules and deadlines for claims and document submissions is crucial.
  3. Potential for Claim Issues: Claim denials or delays may arise, particularly when there’s a disagreement on the order of payment between the two plans. This can lead to frustration and inconvenience for both you and your healthcare provider.
  4. Redundant Coverage: There’s a risk of redundant or unnecessary coverage for certain services or treatments, where both plans provide the same benefits. This redundancy may result in paying more than necessary for identical coverage.

If the idea of dual health insurance plans intrigues you, carefully weigh the pros and cons to determine if the benefits outweigh the drawbacks.

Additionally, understanding and adhering to the coordination of benefits rules for both plans is essential to navigate potential challenges and ensure a smooth process when filing claims.

Making an informed decision is crucial to optimizing the advantages while mitigating the associated complexities.

How To Choose The Best Health Insurance Plan For You

An infographic of How To Choose the Best Health Insurance Plan for You
How To Choose the Best Health Insurance Plan for You
  1. Explore Your Options: Begin by exploring your eligibility for health insurance, whether through your employer, government programs, or the private market. Platforms like and state online marketplaces offer plan comparisons and pricing.
  2. Understand Plan Types: Familiarize yourself with different plan types such as HMOs, PPOs, EPOs, and POS plans. Differentiating in how they cover in-network and out-of-network care, referrals, and benefit coordination, understanding these distinctions is key.
  3. Evaluate Benefits and Coverage: Compare the benefits and coverage offered by each plan. Look for specific services like preventive care, prescription drugs, mental health, maternity, dental, and vision. Utilize the plan’s summary of benefits and coverage to grasp what is included and your associated costs.
  4. Analyze Costs and Savings: Scrutinize the costs and potential savings for each plan. Assess the monthly premium, deductible, copayments, coinsurance, and out-of-pocket maximum. Additionally, check for subsidies or discounts like premium tax credits that can alleviate your financial burden.
  5. Assess Quality of Care: Gauge the quality of care provided by each plan through ratings and reviews. Seek insights from fellow consumers and reputable organizations such as the National Committee for Quality Assurance and the Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems. This information aids in evaluating a plan’s effectiveness in delivering satisfactory care to its members.

Process of Canceling A Health Insurance Plan

The process of discontinuing a health insurance plan varies based on how you acquired it and the reasons behind your decision to cancel. Here are general steps to guide you through the cancellation process:

  1. Reach out directly to the insurance company: Contact the insurance company using the information provided on your insurance card or their website’s “Contact Us” page. Discuss cancellation policies, including specific dates and any applicable waiting periods. Clarify the cancellation date and inquire about potential waiting periods during your conversation with the insurance company representative.
  2. Submit a written cancellation request: Whether online or offline, send a written policy cancellation request to your insurer. Include your policy details and provide a clear reason for cancellation. Depending on the circumstances, you might also be required to furnish proof of your new coverage or additional documents.
  3. Verify the processing of your cancellation: Confirm that your cancellation request has been processed and check for eligibility for a refund. Follow up with the insurance company or review your account statement to ensure the cancellation is finalized without any unexpected fees or penalties.
  4. Update your Marketplace plan if applicable: For those with a Marketplace plan, modify your application on or your state’s online marketplace. Cancel your Marketplace plan either online or via phone, specifying the reason for cancellation and the desired end date of your coverage.

Canceling a health insurance plan is a significant decision that involves complexity.

Before terminating your existing coverage, ensure you have a valid reason for cancellation and have secured a new plan.

Compare the benefits and costs of both plans meticulously to make an informed decision that aligns with your healthcare needs.

How To Avoid Claim Denials Or Delays With Two Health Insurance Plans

  1. Inform Both Plans: Notify both insurance plans about your dual coverage, offering detailed information about the other plan. This aids in determining the primary and secondary payer roles.
  2. Check Coverage Details: Scrutinize the summary of benefits and coverage for both plans to understand what services are covered, ensuring your required treatment is included, and meets medical necessity requirements.
  3. Prefer In-Network Providers: Opt for in-network providers and facilities whenever possible, as they adhere to agreed-upon rates and terms, reducing the risk of higher costs or claim denials.
  4. Secure Prior Authorization: Obtain prior authorization from both plans for services or treatments that necessitate it. This proactive step ensures approval before receiving the service, preventing claim denials or reductions.
  5. Timely and Accurate Filing: File your claims promptly with accurate information, adhering to the rules and deadlines of both plans. Include essential details such as policy information, service details, diagnosis, procedure codes, charges, and payments.
  6. Monitor Financial Responsibilities: Keep tabs on deductibles, copays, coinsurance, and out-of-pocket maximums for both plans. While the secondary plan may cover some costs, be aware of its unique financial requirements.
  7. Review Explanation of Benefits (EOB): Scrutinize EOBs received from both plans after claim processing. Cross-reference them with your bills to identify and rectify any errors or discrepancies promptly.
  8. Appeal Unfair Denials: If faced with claim denials or delays you deem unjust, exercise your right to appeal. Follow the appeal process outlined by your plans, providing supporting evidence to contest the decision.

Frequently asked question

Can you have two health insurance plans? 

  • Yes, you can enroll in more than one health insurance plan, but you will need to pay both premiums and deductibles.

How do two health insurance plans work together? 

  • When you have two health insurance plans, one will be your primary plan and the other will be your secondary plan. The primary plan pays first and the secondary plan pays the balance, according to the coordination of benefits rules.

How to choose the best health insurance plan for you?

Also Read

Leave a Comment