Collector Car Insurance Reviews: Overview, Companies, How it works, Regulatory compliance, Customers review, and Claim Processes

A person in the office with a client discussing collector car insurance reviews.
A person in the office with a client discussing collector car insurance reviews. | photo courtesy | Bing Source: Facebook


Collector car insurance provides unique coverage designed to protect classic, antique, or exotic vehicles from damage, theft, or liability.

Unlike standard car insurance, this specialized coverage relies on the agreed value of your car, eliminating the fluctuations linked to the actual cash value.

You and your insurer decide on this value together, so you can get the same amount if your vehicle gets destroyed or taken.

Collector car insurance, crafted for vehicles with less frequent use and more secure storage, offers lower premiums and higher deductibles than regular car insurance.

Qualifying for collector car insurance involves meeting specific criteria.

This includes owning a car at least 15 years old, having a daily-use vehicle, restricting collector car mileage to under 5,000 miles annually, and storing the collector car in a secure facility.

Choosing a reputable insurer that specializes in collector car insurance is crucial to ensuring you benefit from the best services and coverage.

Collector Car Insurance Overview

Collector car insurance caters to owners of classic, antique, or exotic vehicles, acknowledging their rarity, value, and historical significance.

Notable differences from regular car insurance include:

  1. Agreed value: The coverage is based on the agreed value of the car, preventing depreciation or market fluctuations from affecting its worth.
  2. Lower premiums: Due to reduced usage and secure storage, collector car insurance typically offers lower premiums compared to regular car insurance.
  3. Higher deductibles: Higher deductibles are common, reflecting the higher costs associated with repairing or replacing collector cars.
  4. Specialized coverage: Collector car insurance includes unique coverages such as spare parts coverage, OEM parts coverage, restoration coverage, and roadside assistance.

What are the pros and cons of collector car insurance?

If you’re contemplating choosing collector car insurance, take a moment to weigh its benefits and drawbacks.



Protects your investment by covering damage, theft, or liability Has strict eligibility requirements like car age, mileage limits, and storage
Saves money on premiums and specialized repair options Imposes usage restrictions: no daily driving or commuting
Provides benefits like spare parts coverage and roadside assistance It requires research to choose the right insurer and negotiate value

Top Collector Car Insurance Companies

Some of the leading collector car insurance companies in the market are:

  1. American Collectors Insurance: With over 40 years of experience, it offers flexible coverage options, earning an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau (BBB) and a 4.8 out of 5 rating from Trustpilot.
  2. American Modern: Boasting over 50 years of expertise, it provides comprehensive coverage options, holding an A+ rating from the BBB and a 4.5 out of 5 rating from Trustpilot.
  3. Leland-West: A niche provider with over 30 years of experience, it offers straightforward coverage options and holds an A+ rating from the BBB and a 4.9 out of 5 rating from Trustpilot.

How does collector car insurance work?

The process of obtaining and using collector car insurance involves several steps:

  1. Apply for a quote: Provide necessary information about yourself, your car, and your driving habits to receive a quote.
  2. Choose your coverage: Select liability limits, deductible amounts, and additional coverages based on your needs.
  3. Pay your premium. Pay the agreed-upon amount for your coverage, with frequency options ranging from monthly to annually.
  4. File a claim: In case of a loss, submit a claim detailing the incident, and, if approved, receive the agreed value minus the deductible.

Collector Car Insurance Regulatory Compliance

While regulated by state insurance departments like regular car insurance, classic car insurance may have exemptions or variations.

Here are key points for regulatory compliance:

  • State Oversight: Classic car insurance falls under the jurisdiction of state insurance departments, similar to the oversight applied to standard car insurers.
  • Exceptional Cases and Variances: Certain states may not necessitate specific coverage types, and exemptions related to historical or antique vehicles can have implications for emissions, safety inspections, or registration fees.
  • State-Specific Regulations: It’s vital to grasp the regulatory framework specific to your state, as collector car insurance requirements may vary depending on your location.
  • Open Dialogue with Your Insurer: Engaging in discussions with your insurance provider is essential. This ensures clarity on compliance issues and guarantees adherence to applicable laws and regulations.

Considering these factors will enable you to navigate the regulatory landscape effectively and make well-informed decisions regarding your collector car insurance.

Collector Car Insurance Customers and Testimonials

Passionate collector car owners often express satisfaction with their insurers.

Positive testimonials highlight responsive customer service, competitive rates, and efficient claims handling.

Real customer testimonials indicate high satisfaction levels with American Collectors Insurance, American Modern, and Leland-West.

Here are testimonials from actual customers of classic car insurance sourced from platforms like Trustpilot:

“I’ve been with American Collectors Insurance for over 10 years, and I can’t speak highly enough about them. They’ve consistently shown responsiveness, professionalism, and fairness in handling my claims and inquiries. With competitive rates and excellent coverage options, I wholeheartedly recommend them to any collector car owner.” – John

“For collector car insurance, American Modern is an excellent choice. Their online quote process is quick and straightforward, offering flexibility in coverage selection. Their customer service team is friendly and knowledgeable, ensuring a speedy and efficient handling of claims. I’m thoroughly pleased with their services.” – Lisa

“Leland-West stands out as a fantastic company for collector car insurance. Their policy is simple and transparent, devoid of hidden fees. With a low premium and a high agreed value for my car, coupled with a helpful and courteous customer service team, they make claims processing smooth and hassle-free. I’m genuinely satisfied with their service.” – Mark

While these are just a few examples of positive feedback from classic car insurance customers, there are numerous others available online or from fellow classic car owners.

Classic Car Insurance Claim Process and Customer Service

Classic Car Insurance Claim Process and Customer Service
An infographic illustrating the steps involved in processing classic car insurance claims and highlighting the customer service features.


Essential features to consider in the claim process and customer service include:

  1. Online, phone, or app claim filing: Multiple channels for filing claims provide flexibility and convenience.
  2. 24/7 claim support: Round-the-clock availability ensures timely assistance during emergencies.
  3. Dedicated claim representative: Having a consistent point of contact enhances personal service and understanding of your case.
  4. Agreed value settlement: Receiving the agreed value minus the deductible ensures fairness and accuracy in claim settlements.
  5. OEM parts or specialized repair shops: The option to choose quality parts or specialized repair shops contributes to the authenticity and value of the collector car.


Frequently Asked Questions About Classic Car Insurance

What counts as a collector car?

Any vintage, classic, or antique vehicle that’s valuable as more than just basic transportation.

Generally 20–25+ years old.

Why do I need special insurance?

Regular auto policies don’t provide enough coverage for collector cars that gain value and need spare parts or show coverage.

Does my collector car need a garage?

Yes, most policies require locked private garage storage when not driving to protect against weather, vandalism, and theft.

Can I drive my collector car daily?

No, these specialty policies strictly limit annual mileage, usually 1,500–3,000 miles per year.

Daily drivers don’t qualify.

How much does this specialty insurance cost?

Premiums vary widely based on make, model, age, value, and mileage.

But generally, the rarer the vehicle, the more the coverage costs.

Agreed-value policies cost more than standard ones.

Spread the love

Leave a Comment