How much is car insurance for 16 year olds? Navigating the Expenses

How much is car insurance for 16 year olds?

Obtaining a driver’s license at the age of 16 is a significant achievement for many individuals.

However, the excitement of having a driver’s license may quickly diminish upon realizing the considerable expense associated with insuring a 16-year-old driver.

The cost of car insurance for teenage drivers can be surprisingly steep.

That’s why we have examined insurance rates to assist you in locating the most affordable car insurance options for 16-year-olds.

How much is car insurance for 16 year olds
How much is car insurance for 16 year olds

How Much Is Car Insurance for a 16-Year-Old?

Adding a 16-year-old to a parent’s car insurance policy averages $2,735 annually, equivalent to an extra $230 each month, according to Forbes Advisor’s analysis.

In contrast, the average cost for a 16-year-old driver with their own policy is significantly higher at $8,765 per year or $730 monthly.

Considering the overall family insurance cost, a parent’s car insurance policy with a 16-year-old driver included averages $5,697 annually based on our analysis of various companies.

The optimal car insurance choice combines reasonable total costs with comprehensive coverage.

Insuring 16-year-old drivers is notably expensive due to their limited experience. As newly licensed drivers, 16-year-olds are more prone to accidents and insurance claims, leading to elevated insurance rates.

However, with accumulating experience and a clean record devoid of accidents or traffic violations, the cost of their car insurance is likely to decrease over time.

How much is car insurance for 16 year olds?

What Is the Cheapest Car Insurance for 16-Year-Old Drivers?

Erie stands out as the most affordable car insurance provider when it comes to including a 16-year-old driver in a parent’s car insurance policy, based on the companies assessed.

In general, incorporating a 16-year-old into a parent’s policy is considerably more cost-effective than securing an independent policy for the teenager.

The following outlines the comparison of car insurance expenses for a 16-year-old driver in different scenarios.

Cheapest car insurance for adding a 16-year-old driver

When incorporating a 16-year-old into your current policy, Erie offers a savings of $932 compared to the national average of $2,735, making it the most cost-effective option.

Nationwide follows as the second most affordable insurance company in this context.

What Factors Influence the Cost of Car Insurance for 16-Year-Old Drivers?

Age plays a crucial role in determining car insurance rates, but it is not the sole factor.

Several elements influence the cost of car insurance for 16-year-old drivers:


Adding a teenager to a parent’s auto insurance policy leads to an increased rate because insurance companies perceive inexperienced drivers as high-risk.

While avoiding a significant increase may be challenging, there are steps to mitigate the financial impact.


Car insurance rates are influenced by the claims paid by companies.

Due to teenage males being associated with more claims than their female counterparts, insurance costs are higher for them.

Making a claim may also result in a rate hike during the next renewal.


Various location-related factors affect car insurance costs, including weather and disaster claims (such as hail and floods), the frequency of auto accidents, claims related to auto theft and vandalism, the cost of vehicle repairs (including parts and labor), and the cost of medical care, impacting insurers’ expenses for injury claims.

Type of Car:

The choice of purchasing collision and comprehensive insurance affects auto insurance payments for claims related to car theft, vehicle damage from crashes, incidents like backing into poles, or having trees fall on the car.

If the car is more expensive to repair or replace compared to other vehicles, this additional cost is reflected in rates for collision and comprehensive coverage.

What Discounts Are Available for 16-Year-Olds?

Locating numerous car insurance discounts for 16-year-olds may be challenging due to their reputation as high-risk drivers often involved in insurance claims.

Nonetheless, it’s worthwhile to explore potential eligibility for any available discounts for your teen.

Good student discount

If your 16-year-old driver qualifies, obtaining a “good student discount” is an obvious choice.

However, it may be necessary to request this discount, as your car insurance company might not automatically apply it.

Based on Forbes Advisor’s examination of good student discounts, an average savings of 4% can be expected.

The criteria for eligibility in this discount may vary slightly among companies, but generally, the student should fall within a specific age range, attend high school or college full-time, and maintain satisfactory grades.

Typically, meeting the criteria for a “good student” involves:

  1. Being in the upper 20% of their class.
  2. Maintaining a grade average of B or better.
  3. Achieving an average of 3.0 or better.
  4. Being on the Dean’s List, Honor Roll, or a comparable listing.
  5. Being in the upper 20% of a national standardized test within the past 12 months, such as the PSAT.

Discount for a driver training class

While less frequently available, this discount can be valuable if provided by your insurance provider.

By enrolling your 16-year-old in an authorized driver training program, you may qualify for a training discount.

It’s crucial to confirm the course’s approval for the discount before relying on it to secure a reduced premium..

How to Get the Cheapest Insurance Policy at 16

Here are some suggestions for obtaining the most affordable car insurance for a 16-year-old:

Get Multiple Quotes:

After adding a 16-year-old to your car insurance policy, the previously cost-effective company for parents may no longer offer competitive rates.

It’s advisable to compare car insurance quotes to identify more favorable deals.

Explore Discount Opportunities:

Concentrate on securing good student discounts and price reductions for completing a driver’s education class.

Additionally, inquire with your car insurance agent about other potential discounts applicable to families with a 16-year-old driver.

Drive an Affordable Car:

Opt for a reasonably priced vehicle, as collision and comprehensive insurance costs less for cars that are cheaper to repair or replace.

While ensuring your teen has a reliable and safe vehicle, avoid luxury cars, and especially steer clear of sports cars to maintain reasonable insurance rates.

Increase Your Deductibles:

In cases where you purchase collision and comprehensive insurance, selecting a higher deductible, such as $1,000 instead of $500, can often result in cost savings.

Consult your car insurance agent for quotes on various higher deductible options, weighing the savings against the higher likelihood of a 16-year-old driver being involved in an accident.

Coverage Amount:

While considering cost-saving measures, refrain from reducing coverage, especially with a 16-year-old driver.

Teens have a higher likelihood of being in car accidents, making robust auto insurance coverage essential to handle potential claims effectively.

Why is car insurance so expensive for 16-year-olds?

Car insurance is pricier for 16-year-olds due to their higher accident risk.

Teen drivers are three times likelier to have fatal crashes, per the CDC.

Higher rates result from a lack of sufficient data for accurate modeling.

Premiums are influenced by driving history, favoring those with accident-free years.

Limited data for teens with licenses for a year or less hinders accurate risk assessment, leading to higher costs.

Spread the love

Leave a Comment