Physicians Mutual Dental Insurance Reviews, Coverage, Financials

In the complex realm of dental insurance, it’s crucial to navigate choices just like you do with flossing.

Physicians Mutual, a long-standing insurance provider with a century of service, is often mentioned.

But how good is their dental insurance? To find out, let’s explore customer reviews and ratings and uncover the truth.

Physicians mutual dental insurance reviews
Physicians Mutual offers a diverse range of dental plans catering to individuals, families, and older people. [Photo: Bobby Brock Insurance]

Physicians Mutual Dental Insurance Reviews

Physicians Mutual Dental Insurance presents both pros and cons. It stands out for being affordable, providing robust preventive care coverage, and offering flexibility in its network.

However, it’s important to note potential drawbacks, such as limitations in major service coverage, waiting periods, and network size.

Before deciding, it’s crucial to assess your specific needs and compare options with those of other providers.

Remember, reviews provide valuable insights, but they don’t tell the whole story. To make an informed decision, take these additional steps:

  • Research plan details: Carefully review the specific coverage of each plan, paying attention to co-pays, deductibles, waiting periods, and limitations.
  • Compare with other providers: Get quotes and compare coverage options from other dental insurance companies to find the best fit for your budget and needs.
  • Contact Physicians Mutual: If you have specific questions or concerns, directly contact Physicians Mutual for clarification.

Physicians Mutual Dental Insurance Reviews: Plans and Coverage Options

Physicians Mutual divides their plans into four tiers, each designed for different needs and budgets:

  1. Bronze Plans: These plans focus on the essentials, providing 100% coverage for preventive care such as cleanings and exams. They offer limited coverage for major services like fillings and crowns, making them ideal for individuals in good oral health seeking routine maintenance.
  2. Silver Plans: Offering a step up in protection, Silver Plans extend coverage to include fillings and crowns with moderate co-pays and deductibles. Think of it as a shield against occasional dental issues.
  3. Gold Plans: Geared toward those anticipating potential dental challenges, Gold plans increase coverage percentages for major services like root canals and dentures, resulting in lower out-of-pocket expenses. They are a great choice for families or individuals expecting future dental work.
  4. Platinum Plans: Providing the ultimate shield and sword, Platinum plans offer maximum protection with no co-pays or deductibles for most services. Perfect for those seeking peace of mind and the freedom to smile without financial worry.

Coverage Details

Now, let’s explore the specifics of each tier, uncovering the benefits:

  • Preventive Care: All plans, from Bronze to Platinum, offer 100% coverage for preventive care such as cleanings, exams, and X-rays, ensuring regular maintenance is covered for a healthy smile.
  • Major Services: Coverage for major services like fillings, crowns, root canals, and dentures varies across tiers. Bronze plans offer minimal coverage, while Silver and Gold plans provide increasing percentages of coverage, leading to lower out-of-pocket expenses. Platinum plans cover almost all major services with no cost-sharing surprises.
  • Additional Benefits: Some plans include extra perks like orthodontic coverage, periodontics, and vision insurance. Explore each plan’s details to discover hidden gems that suit your specific needs.
Physicians Mutual Dental Insurance Reviews
Most plans boast 100% coverage for cleanings, exams, and other preventive services. [Photo: Money Geek]

Choosing the Right Plan

With numerous options, selecting the perfect plan requires strategic pondering. Consider these factors:

  • Budget: Determine your comfortable monthly premium and choose a plan that fits your financial constraints.
  • Dental Health: Analyze your current oral health and anticipate potential future needs. If minor maintenance suffices, a Bronze plan might be sufficient. However, if major work looms, a gold or platinum plan might be wiser.
  • Family Needs: If covering families, consider plans with higher coverage percentages for major services to prevent collective out-of-pocket expenses.
  • Network Considerations: Decide how important in-network access is to you. In-network providers offer discounted rates, but out-of-network options provide greater flexibility.

Customer Service

Reviews of customer service paint a mixed picture.

Some reviewers report prompt and helpful assistance from representatives, while others mention long wait times and frustration with unresolved issues.

It seems consistency might be a concern, and individual experiences may vary.

Financial Strength and Ratings

Financial Strength: Physicians Mutual boasts a solid financial footing, evident in several key metrics:

  • Assets: Over $2.79 billion in assets demonstrates their ability to meet financial obligations and sustain claims payouts.
  • Claims Paid: $367 million in annual claims paid reflects their commitment to honoring member coverage and providing financial support.
  • Profitability: Consistent profitability year after year signifies financial stability and the ability to reinvest in their services.


  • A.M. Best: “A” for both Physicians Mutual Insurance Company and Physicians Life Insurance Company signifies excellent financial strength and the ability to meet long-term obligations.
  • Weiss Ratings: “A+” for Physicians Mutual Insurance Company and “A-” for Physicians Life Insurance Company underscore their exceptional financial security and stability.
  • Better Business Bureau (BBB): An A+ rating indicates a strong commitment to customer satisfaction and resolving complaints effectively.

Physicians Mutual Dental Insurance Reviews: Claims Process

People have different opinions about the claims process. Some like how easy it is to submit claims online and get money back quickly.

Others complain about delays, denials, and too much paperwork. To avoid possible delays, it’s important to have all the necessary information and respond to any extra requests.

Physicians mutual dental insurance
The claims process receives both praise and criticism. Some reviewers appreciate the ease of online claim submission and prompt reimbursement. [Image:]

Weighing the Pros and Cons

Deciding on the right dental insurance involves balancing your needs and options.

Let’s explore the advantages and disadvantages of Physicians Mutual Dental Insurance to help you determine if it’s the right fit for your teeth:


  1. Affordability: Many reviewers say Physicians Mutual offers competitive premiums compared to other providers.
  2. Flexible Network: You can choose any dentist, in-network or out-of-network, and still get coverage. This saves you from the hassle of finding an in-network dentist, but be aware that out-of-network costs might be higher.
  3. Preventive Care Coverage: Most plans provide 100% coverage for preventive care like cleanings and exams, promoting ongoing oral health maintenance.
  4. No Deductibles or Annual Maximums: Some plans, especially for older people, remove deductibles and annual maximums for cash benefits, giving predictable coverage for preventive care.
  5. Strong Financial Standing: With an A+ rating from the BBB and excellent financial strength ratings from A.M. Best and Weiss Ratings, Physicians Mutual demonstrates reliability and the ability to cover claims.


  1. Limited Major Service Coverage: While preventive care is well-covered, some reviewers complain about lower coverage percentages for major services like fillings, crowns, and dentures, leading to significant out-of-pocket expenses.
  2. Wait Periods: Waiting periods for certain services, especially major ones, can be inconvenient for individuals needing urgent dental work.
  3. Network Size: While national, the Physicians Mutual network is not as extensive as some larger competitors, limiting dentist choices in certain areas.
  4. Claims Issues: Some reviewers report difficulties with claim processing, delays, or denials, causing frustration and additional expenses.
  5. Inconsistent Customer Service: While some praise customer service, others report negative experiences with long wait times and unhelpful representatives.

Spread the love