Who Elects The Governing Body Of A Mutual Insurance Company? A Comprehensive Analysis

Who Elects The Governing Body Of A Mutual Insurance Company?

Mutual insurance companies are governed by a board of directors elected by, and sometimes comprised of, policyholders.

Describing medical professional liability (malpractice) insurers as “mutual” means that the policyholders collectively own the company.

When you invest in a policy from a mutual medical professional liability insurance company, you gain an ownership stake in the company, similar to buying stock or participating in a mutual fund.

Physicians securing their malpractice insurance typically face a choice between policyholder-owned mutual companies and stock companies, owned by shareholders.

Who Elects The Governing Body Of A Mutual Insurance Company
Who Elects The Governing Body Of A Mutual Insurance Company: Photo(Management Notes)


Mutual insurers prioritize long-term strategies to satisfy policyholders, allowing them to influence the company’s direction and product offerings.

In contrast, stock companies focus on short-term approaches to meet stock market expectations and generate profits for investors.

While both types earn income from policy premiums and investments, stock companies can also raise funds by selling stocks.

Due to their ownership structure, mutual insurance companies often exhibit a more service-oriented approach.

Moreover, since they lack the option to sell stocks for income, they tend to uphold stricter underwriting discipline and adopt a more conservative investment approach to safeguard the shared assets of policyholders.

The Origins and Advantages of Mutual Insurance Companies

The concept of mutually owned insurance companies traces back to 17th-century England, with Benjamin Franklin establishing the first one in the United States in the mid-18th century.

These entities typically emerge to address specific market gaps or needs.

In the medical professional liability insurance industry, mutual companies often arise during a “hard market” characterized by increased malpractice claims;

Causing poorly managed companies to close and larger carriers to reduce medical malpractice coverage due to diminished profit potential.

The significant hard market of the mid-1970s led to the formation of mutually owned insurance companies by groups and associations of physicians.

Also Read: Which Type Of Life Insurance Policy Generates Immediate Cash Value?

These entities aimed to provide affordable and reliable coverage, specializing in healthcare and typically operating within a specific state or geographic region.

This transformative move shifted the market dynamics, making many of the country’s largest carriers in medical malpractice insurance mutual entities.

Benefits of Mutual Insurance Companies

While specific reasons may guide the choice of a medical professional liability insurance carrier, mutual insurers offer policyholders distinctive advantages:


Mutual owners share in the company’s success, receiving financial rewards in the form of dividends.

If the company meets or exceeds its financial goals, a portion of profits is returned to policyholders as dividends, reducing premium payments or providing cash back.


As owners, policyholders have a voice in the company’s governance.

Mutual insurance companies are governed by a board of directors elected by, and sometimes comprised of, policyholders.

This ensures that the company operates in the best interests of policyholders, contrasting with stock insurance companies directed by boards chosen to meet the financial goals of external investors.


Ownership incentivizes better performance, guided by a policyholder-led board of directors.

Mutual companies may implement robust risk management programs or stringent underwriting requirements to reduce claim likelihood.

Fewer claims translate to higher potential profits and greater dividends, making the success of the insurer a tangible impact on policyholders’ financial well-being.


Established by associations or groups with a common interest, mutual companies maintain a focused approach to product offerings.

In medical professional liability insurance, this means dedicated service to the healthcare market.

By concentrating on a specific area, mutuals provide in-depth expertise, targeted resources:

And skilled support compared to stock companies with broader customer bases and coverage offerings.

Spread the love